The Bastille: Living hell and 5-star hotel

1789 drawing of "L'homme au Masque de Fer," the Man in the Iron MaskA new exhibit at the Arsenal Library branch of the French National Library called “La Bastille, or a Living Hell” is putting on display archives and artifacts of life inside the Bastille, fortress, prison and symbol of royal injustice whose destruction launched a revolution. The prison archives were thrown into ditches by the Parisians who stormed the Bastille on the 14th of July 1789. Nine years passed before the administrator of the Arsenal Library was able to get his hands on them, and there they remained generating surprisingly little interest for the next couple hundred years.

This exhibit is the first time the archives and artifacts have been gathered together for a comprehensive look at how prisoners in the Bastille really lived, as opposed to the fictional representations of revolutionary misinformation and propaganda. The high profile prisoners like Voltaire and the Marquis de Sade actually led a pretty cushy existence, complete with suites of rooms, their own furniture and dinner parties with outside guests.

Clothing belonging to prisoner DamiensEven the poor prisoners — forgers, printers, Huguenots — lived in far more comfortable conditions than prisoners in any other prison in Paris. They each had their own cells and the prison could only hold a maximum of 50 prisoners, so there wasn’t anything like the squalor and horror that characterized most prisons.

They were still in a 14th century fortress, though, locked behind 3 triple-locked doors, with highly restricted, censored communications and enforced secrecy. Prisoners were sent to the Bastille by secret order of the King. There was no trial, not even any explanation of the charges.

People were not put in the Bastille for crimes such as theft or murder. They were there for troubling the social order. This included Protestants, homosexuals, prostitutes, traitors, and anyone who dared say anything against the king or his reign — which meant most of the prisoners were authors, publishers and book peddlers.

Life inside the Bastille had its limitations, and communications with the outside world were strictly controlled. One prisoner sent a message on his handkerchief written out of coffee and soot, on display in the exhibit. Another smuggled his out in a cheese. One prisoner sewed a message onto a piece of cloth, claiming his innocence and asking whoever found it to help him.

“Secret is the word that defines this prison. Prisoners who left the Bastille would have to sign a register promising to never talk about the prisoners they saw in the Bastille or what they lived through,” Dutray said.

One story in the archives describes a terminally ill Protestant woman who was sent to the Bastille. Her daughter was allowed to accompany her even though the daughter was not technically under arrest. She remained by her mother’s side, hiding the truth of how ill her mother was from her captors to ensure she would not be forcibly converted to Catholicism, until her death. Once the woman died, officials didn’t want to release the daughter because she might talk, so they just kept her prisoner in the Bastille for a few years until finally sending her to a convent for the newly converted.

It was that secrecy which fed the rumors of torture and dark doings that would make the Bastille a symbol of royal abuse and a primary revolutionary target. When 8000 people stormed it on what would become known as Bastille Day, they found only 7 prisoners inside and a cache of gunpowder and weapons. They released the prisoners, dumped the archives, killed the governor and some of the guards, and the next day began to demolish the fortress itself.

Miniature of the Bastille carved out of stone from the Bastille (Carnavalet Museum).Today there are only a few stones of it left on Boulevard Henri IV, a miniature sculpture of the fortress carved out of one the building stones, a door and a few keys. Two of those keys are on display at the Arsenal Library exhibit.

Mount Vernon Bastille key, photograph by Alfred Eisenstaedt, 1944, LIFE magazineOne of them is part of the permanent collection of Mount Vernon. The Marquis de Lafayette presented the key to the west portal of the Bastille to George Washington along with a sketch of the fortress. In a letter dated March 17, 1790, he wrote “Give me leave, my dear General to present you with a picture of the Bastille, just as it looked a few days after I had ordered its demolition, with the main key of the fortress of despotism. It is a tribute, which I owe, as a son to my adoptive father, as an Aide-de-Camp to my General, as a Missionary of liberty to its Patriarch.”

11 thoughts on “The Bastille: Living hell and 5-star hotel

  1. It always bugs me when people denigrate the French given their long and glorious history. After all, we only won independence with their help, but their revolution succeeded without foreign aid and considerable opposition.

    1. I don’t know if it succeeded, exactly. It wasn’t able to create a stable democratic government, for instance. Of course, if all of Europe hadn’t sent armies after them things might have gone differently, and no doubt modern democracies owe enormous amounts to the French Revolution.

      Also, they invented the coolest month names. All hail Thermidor!

      1. It can be hard for established republics to keep extremists out of power during a constant state of wartime. They were pretty much at war with the rest of the continent until Napoleon’s time and even then it was only because he was knocking off opponents like flies for awhile.

  2. I always thought the stay of fictional Doctor Manette in the Bastille in Dickens’ Tale of Two Cities sounded rather cushy. He had his own room, a window, meals, and was allowed to make his shoes all day. It seems like the worst of the stay would be social isolation. It’s surprising to hear that it wasn’t that much of a stretch from the reality of things.

    As for the real 7 prisoners, I wonder if there is any account of who they were or what happenned to them after the Storming. IT would be interesting to know if any took part in the revolution or if the fled the country or whatever.

    1. I’ve looked for details on their fate, but none of my FR books have come through. They were all petty criminals, though. No prisoners of conscience (mainly Hugenots) or political prisoners (mainly publishers of anti-monarchical tracts). Most of them were forgers.

  3. Thank you! This is going to help me so much in November when I am writing my Nanowrimo novel!

  4. I’ve read years before that the Bastille was indeed a 5-star hotel instead of a supposed nasty daily torture prison where France’s lowest and foulest criminals would pay their debts to society! This confirms it! Ah the dangers of disinformation, right? 😆

  5. Actually, as I’ve now proved in my book (“George Washington’s Liberty Key”), the Mount Vernon Bastille Key was to the most important entrance, the pedestrian entrance on the south side of the Bastille. At the time of the Storming, 14 July 1789, the western portal had been blocked up. Thanks! http://www.LibertyKey.US

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.