Scandal! Vasari archives sold to Russian firm

Giorgio Vasari self portrait, 1566-68A major scandal is brewing in Italy over the recent revelation that the heirs of the late Count Giovanni Festari sold the archive of documents and sketches by Renaissance artist and architect Giorgio Vasari to Russian firm Ross Engineering for a jaw-dropping 150 million euros ($225 million).

Vasari was a fine Mannerist artist and architect in his own right, but today he is best known as the biographer of the most famous artists of Renaissance and Middle Ages. He wrote about them in what is widely acknowledged as the first art historical biography, his Lives of Artists.

This is a foundational work of art history, and his archives contain not only his own notes and sketches, but also correspondence with five popes, Michelangelo and Cosimo de’ Medici, his patron and the ruler of Florence.

Considerable mystery surrounds the sale of Vasari’s papers, which are kept in the house the artist bought for himself in his home town and which he decorated with his own frescoes. The mayor of Arezzo [Giuseppe Fanfani] said he had only learned of the transaction in a letter from a government official which said it had taken place on 23 September – days before the death of the owner of the archive, Giovanni Festari.

The letter informed him that, under the terms of a 1994 government order, he could block the sale by matching the price supposedly offered by a Russian company. “Madness,” said the mayor. “Where am I going to find €150m? That’s equivalent to five times the annual budget of the Arezzo council.”

And he has just six months to match the price or the sale becomes official. The cost is so exorbitant that there is some speculation that it’s not the actual selling price, but a deliberate deception to ensure that it can’t possibly be matched by the town of Arezzo, or the whole region of Tuscany for that matter.

By law, the archive can’t leave Arezzo, but that is little consolation to the mayor. Laws change, after all, and he can’t imagine that the Russians would be content with owning it long distance forever.

A lawyer representing Ross Engineering says they know they can’t move the archive and they have “no problem” leaving it in Arezzo. ”Who knows?” he says. “Maybe they want to have an exhibition and open them up to the public?”

I would say that perhaps their spokesperson might know, should he bother to ask. This kind of vague response is hardly reassuring.

Italy is planning a series of celebrations of Vasari’s 500th birthday next year. If this sale goes through, that would put a major damper on the festivities.

Roman prosecutors are looking into the sale right now. According to Tuscany culture chief Diana Toccafondi, the archive was recently thoroughly renovated using state funds, and the government has expended considerable resources before to keep it out of fureign hands.

Mayor Fanfani isn’t letting this go. He has appealed to the regional parliament, the Russian ambassador, Culture Minister Sandro Bondi and Premier Silvio Berlusconi, who is actually in Russia this week meeting with Vladimir Putin.

I hope against hope this issue makes it at least as high on the agenda as Russian hookers and comparing tans.

The Castration of Uranus by Saturn, fresco by Vasari

Share

RSS feed

7 Comments »

Comment by Clutch
2009-10-25 09:39:45

By law, the archive can’t leave Arezzo, but that is little consolation to the mayor. Laws change, after all…

Premier Silvio Berlusconi… is actually in Russia this week meeting with Vladimir Putin.

There’s an obvious worry, right enough. For $50,000 and a handjob from a 17 year-old model, Berlusconi would change practically any law governing something like papers. Especially to indulge a fellow Caesar like Putin.

Comment by livius drusus
2009-10-25 12:08:33

My thoughts exactly. If Putin gives a crap at all (which I doubt he does), it’ll most likely be in support of croneymen. Meanwhile, the Festari family lawyer is declaring this a state persecution of poor, innocent property-holders. I see no reason to believe Mr. Dirty Capitalism & Handjobs is going to fight for the state’s rights in this.

 
 
Comment by Jeffry W
2009-10-26 12:21:58

The Italian people and government cannot and must not let this sale to go through, considering how important Vasari’s correspondence is. Too much Italian history lost already to the foreign hands. What’s the point of going to a great length reclaiming ancient artifacts from major museums, if you can’t save this very important documents?

It’s saddening how some greedy Italians present and the past are willing to sell their rich country history for a few more bucks (Assuming the actual sales is closer 20-30 million euros, a price that is more within the reach of the state to match. Of course 10-20 million euros is just not a few more bucks, but again can you not live and be satisfied with 20-30 million euros?)

 
Comment by Hels
2009-10-26 23:54:26

Every country in the world has faced this very question: what can be done to stop that country’s cultural objects from being taken away?

It is bad enough when the objects were stolen by private individuals or even looted by an invading army. The courts move so slowly that public galleries and museums almost never get their objects back.

But it is almost impossible when the sale was legal and fair market value was paid. When Gainsborough’s Blue Boy was about to be taken off to America, the National Gallery allowed viewers to come and stand before the painting in tears of loss. Huntington’s name in the 1920s was as accursed as Ross Engineering’s name will be now.

Comment by Jeffry W
2009-10-28 08:50:39

Funny how you mentioned the feeling of the London public when the Blue Boy was carted off the U.S, but what about the Parthenon marbles, the Benin Bronzes, the Rosetta Stone, and countless priceless artifacts the Britain looted from their native lands?

What is your opinion on those loots, should they be returned to their rightful owners, to their birth of places? Surely Britain must have something of their own to display on their museums. Right?

 
 
Comment by M
2009-11-03 16:25:48

Your post caught my attention several days ago, and I’ve been following this story. Have you seen this recent article which suggests that the Vasari sale might be a prank? See here: http://www.thearttribune.com/Is-the-sale-of-the-Vasari-archives.html

Comment by livius drusus
2009-11-11 23:13:14

I have read about that. I would say Vittorio Sgarbi thinks it’s a more of a scam than a prank, a ploy by the Festari heirs to force the government to purchase the papers for way above their estimated value.

 
 
Name
E-mail
URI

;) :yes: :thanks: :skull: :shifty: :p :ohnoes: :notworthy: :no: :love: :lol: :hattip: :giggle: :facepalm: :evil: :eek: :cry: :cool: :confused: :chicken: :boogie: :blush: :blankstare: :angry: :D :) :(

Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)

You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.