MoMA finds lost 1913 film with all-black cast

New York City’s Museum of Modern Art has discovered footage of a previously unknown 1913 film with vaudeville and Broadway pioneer Bert Williams starring in a cast of all black actors. It’s not a completed film that a movie theater would have received, but rather seven reels of unassembled daily rushes, multiple takes from each scene, that the director and editor would later edit together into the finished picture. The museum discovered the footage in its collection of 900 negatives from the Biograph studios that were rescued from destruction by MoMA’s first film curator, Iris Barry, when the company’s Bronx warehouse closed in 1939.

It is the earliest surviving film to feature an all-black cast, and is among the earliest ever shot. The Foster Photoplay Company, a Chicago film production company founded in 1910 by theatrical promoter and entertainment journalist William Foster, released what is thought to be the first all-black picture, The Railroad Porter, in June of 1913. MoMA researchers discovered that the Bert Williams film was shot in September of 1913. None of the early Foster Photoplay movies have survived. (Unrelated but interesting coincidence: William Foster worked as a publicity promoter for Bert Williams and his partner George Walker’s groundbreaking 1903 musical In Dahomey, the first full-length musical comedy written and performed by African-Americans to be staged in a Broadway theater, and its equally successful 1906 follow-up Abyssinia.)

Unlike the Foster pictures which were created, shot and performed by black artists, only the actors in the recently discovered footage were black. They were employed by the famed Biograph Company, the film production company which launched the careers of D. W. Griffith, Mack Sennet, Mary Pickford, Lilian Gish, Mabel Normand and Lionel Barrymore. Biograph hired Bert Williams, who by then was hugely famous for his vaudeville routines, musicals and best-selling song recordings, to star in their all-black comedies. He had to wear blackface, which is as incongruous as it is gross considering that none of the other actors (that I can see in the stills, at least) are in blackface.

Even though it includes elements of minstrelsy, the general subject matter and approach does appear to be more in keeping with the “race films” that Foster and other black producers made to counter the ugly stereotypical caricatures of on-screen minstrel pictures.

Of historical relevance is the display of adult romantic feelings between black performers, which was largely considered unacceptable to white audiences into the first two decades of the 20th century. In the film, a repeated, lengthy kiss between Williams and his costar appears to be the earliest surviving portrayal of a serious romantic relationship between black characters on film. The film also features a lengthy early example of African American vernacular dance, with a nearly two-minute, full-cast performance of a cakewalk, the dance that Williams and partners George Walker and Aida Overton Walker had made an international sensation with theater audiences and the white upper class around 1900.

Although no main title, intertitles, script, or production credits have survived with the film, MoMA’s curators tried to reconstruct the film’s narrative, ultimately piecing together what appears to be a middle-class comedy centered on the membership of Williams’s character in a black social club, with an additional plotline concerning Williams and rival suitors vying for the hand of the local beauty after a day of fairground activities, a bit of larceny, and a night of exhibition dancing.

The plot and characters of the film aren’t the only historically significant elements of this find. There’s also behind-the-scenes footage of the black cast interacting with the white crew on set in New York City and on location in what curators believe is Englewood, New Jersey.

The unedited rushes and MoMA’s research will go on display at the museum’s 100 Years in Post-Production: Resurrecting a Lost Landmark of Black Film History exhibition on October 24th. The assembled footage will be screened at MoMA’s 12th annual film preservation festival To Save and Project on November 8th.

Meanwhile, here’s a 1916 Biograph picture starring Bert Williams that has survived intact. As with the cakewalk scene in the recently discovered film, A Natural Born Gambler features one of Bert Williams’ most famous vaudeville routines. It’s the final scene of the picture (beginning at 19:30) in which Williams pantomimes an entire poker game alone.

The Internet Archive, bless its generous heart, has an impressive collection of Bert Williams’ music. His recordings were wildly successful, selling in the hundreds of thousands back when a record that moved 10,000 copies was considered a best-seller. His most famous was probably Nobody, but my favorite is 1920’s When The Moon Shines on The Moonshine both because it’s catchy and because it’s such a perfect little window into the first year of Prohibition.

16 thoughts on “MoMA finds lost 1913 film with all-black cast

  1. In the film, a repeated, lengthy kiss between Williams and his costar appears to be the earliest surviving portrayal of a serious romantic relationship between black characters on film.

    Given that Williams was in blackface, what about this as an early instance of what was actually an interracial kiss being filmed? Do you know if there were other examples earlier?

    1. Like Cheryl said, Bert Williams was a black man. In order for black entertainers to break into the business, they had to start up wearing the same makeup that white performers wore in the minstrel shows. That’s how Bert Williams started out, doing the standard Zip Coon-style blackface characters, and when he was hired by Biograph, they made him wear the makeup even for characters that were more fully fleshed out and real.

  2. Those close up shots of blackface are so uncomfortable to look at. I can’t give enough credit to the black people who lived through those times without either losing their self-respect or punching people.

    That’s a great question Carol has about the interracial kiss, too.

    And I need to find a way to see this cakewalk scene!

    1. And Bert Williams was a bona fide star, too, but not even he could ditch the absurd and offensive big white lips and cork-darkened face. He was black, though. Sadly, being black didn’t stop a performer from being required to wear blackface.

    1. I love that you can see the antecedents of dances like the Lindy in the evolution of plantation traditions like the cakewalk, which started out as slaves satirizing the airs and formality of the masters’ dances.

  3. Carol, Bert Williams was actually a black man who was in blackface in this film. So, it’s not so much an interracial kiss, as what I perceive as an even more uncomfortable situation to have endured, being that he was in fact black & wearing blackface. I can’t even imagine what kind of a mind trip that might have played on him. Though awesomely, the film per this article, seemed to be bucking the stereotypes portrayed by most media at the time. And he enjoyed an immense amount of success. His wiki is filled with awesomeness, check it out.

    1. Thank you, Cheryl. I should have specified that Bert Williams was black. It does seem counterintuitive that black people were made to don blackface. At the same time, it underscores the gross caricature that was the minstrel show since actual black people looked nothing like the makeup and thus had to wear it themselves in order to break into the industry.

      Bert Williams was a genuine superstar. I hope this discovery results in a new revival of interest in his immense talents and many career milestones.

  4. Jive, whatever traditional tap dance moves are called, and breakdancing come to mind when I watch, although now that you mention it, I see the Lindy in there, too. And the James Brown split!

    You’re right, it’s awesome to think that all those modern dances descend from slaves mocking the masters. I love it!

    1. I’m afraid it’s a software bug. The replies don’t nest anymore. When I finally do the long-planned upgrade to this site, that problem along with many other seen and unseen will be fixed. Sorry about the confusion.

  5. Ah, thanks for the clarification. It did seem odd to me that it was considered an all-black cast yet there was someone in blackface, but it didn’t occur to me that a black person would wear it too. That’s an extra layer of awfulness.

  6. I’m not able to find any information on MoMA’s recovery on their site. Is it available to watch somewhere in any format analog or digital?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.